Over the next two years Wisconsin and national Democrats will be in constant danger of losing the plot.
Voters put them in power as a rejection of all things Donald Trump. If they have any mandate at all it is to do something (anything!) about high prices and maybe about the Trump Crime Family’s boundless corruption.
Voters did not elect them to change how we elect presidents. But there will likely be a push in Wisconsin to do just that. Swing voters here will see that and think, “what the huh?”
Here’s the deal. Opponents of the Electoral College have been quietly rigging up a system to do an end around. They know they can’t get a Constitutional amendment to abolish it through the requisite number of states. So instead they’re trying to pass interstate compacts under which states would agree to assign their Electoral College votes (equal to their number of Senators and House members) based on the nationwide popular vote, not the vote in their state.
Democrats like this idea because twice in this century the Democratic winners of the popular vote (Al Gore in 2000 and Hillary Clinton in 2016) won the popular vote but lost in the College. They argue that this violates the principle of one man, one vote because small states get outsized weight given that they get two Senators and at least one Congressman regardless of their population. In the Senate, North Dakota with 800,000 people is equal to New York with 20 million and that echos in the Electoral College.
The compact idea is likely to get a big push now because five more states, including Wisconsin, have new Democratic trifectas. And those five plus the states that have already adopted this would bring the total Electoral College votes represented to more than the 270 needed to elect a president. That would trigger the compact.
But here’s why this is a bad idea.
First, it means that states like Wisconsin will become true flyover country. Candidates will spend all their time in California, New York, Texas and Florida, where the most voters live. Maybe they’ll touch down in Chicago and some parts of Ohio, but otherwise the Midwest will be off the map.

Second, Democrats like this idea only because they’ve lost two recent elections where the Electoral College result conflicted with the popular vote. They would feel differently if Republican candidates had been the victims. But imagine this scenario. In 2028 Kamala Harris defeats J.D. Vance in Wisconsin. She would win in the Electoral College. Democrats are ecstatic. But wait. We pledged to assign our votes based on the national vote where Vance has eked out a narrow victory. Sorry, folks, we’ve got to assign our 10 votes to J.D. Better luck next time.
Third, this is likely a fool’s errand. There’s a good legal argument to be made that interstate compacts require Congressional approval. That would mean this would need 60 votes to beat a filibuster in the Senate, which won’t happen. Moreover, even some sensible Democrats from small states might not vote for it. And if all this ends up before the Supreme Court what’s your guess as to how they’ll rule? In other words, this is all a waste of time.
And finally and most importantly, this will be spun by Republicans as Democrats wanting California to tell Wisconsinites who their next president will be. And, oh by the way, what’s this got to do with the cost of groceries or a gallon of gas?
This move is part of a broader problem. The hard-left wants to eliminate the Senate altogether and even main stream liberals want to stack the Supreme Court and eliminate the filibuster. They’re letting their frustrations with current conditions lead them to favor rash overhauls of a fundamentally sound system. It never seems to occur to them that the speed bumps they seek to remove could be used in their favor in the future. Indeed, the filibuster has been used multiple times in recent years to thwart conservative legislation.
Focus, people, focus. It’s all about prices. Leave the Electoral College alone.