Let’s just say for the sake of argument (and my sanity) that Joe Biden does the right thing, or is forced to do the right thing, and steps aside. Who replaces him?
If it’s Kamala Harris or Gavin Newsom we might as well stick with Joe.
Harris has a minus 20 net approval rating. Only 36% of Americans approve of her performance in office while 56% disapprove. In a head-to-head match-up with Donald Trump she loses by six points while Biden only loses by four. So how are we any better off with Harris?
The obvious answer is that we’re not, but there is a part of the Democratic Party that is so identity obsessed that they would rather move ahead with a candidate almost sure to lose, but who happens to be a Black woman, than nominate someone with a much better chance of beating Trump.
Rep. Jim Clyburn, for whom I have a lot of respect in general, had this to say after Thursday’s debate debacle: “I’m a Biden-Harris person, OK? So I’m not getting away from that. I’m going to be for Biden, if Harris ain’t there, and I’ll be for Harris, if Biden ain’t there.”
Donna Brazile, political strategist and former interim DNC chair, also said that if there were an effort to bypass Harris, “there would be an uproar.”
“Joe Biden placed her on the ticket for a reason and they won in 2020,” she said. “Any attempt to try to change a horse after the voters have selected the team they want to see on the team, there would be total chaos.”
Well, that’s just nuts. Clyburn and Brazile are saying that they are not wavering from supporting two equally unpopular candidates. I thought the point of a political party was to win elections.
Her supporters argue that Harris is only unpopular because of her gender and skin color. I doubt that. I think she’s unpopular because she exudes the same elitist sense of entitlement that Hillary Clinton did. She’s only been successful as a California politician and that is a very different world than national politics. What plays is Palo Alto won’t play in Peoria.
And what if it were true that her identity made her less likely to win? Of course that would be terrible but, again, the point is to beat Trump. If people oppose Harris for awful reasons it doesn’t change the fact that she’s less electable. Do you really want to nominate a Black woman just nominate a Black woman or is the point to keep the most awful man ever to occupy the White House out of it?
And speaking of California the same applies to its governor, Gavin Newsom. If he were the nominee he’d spend the entire campaign defending the indefensible — California’s high taxes, homeless problem, population loss, embrace of reparations and more.
Harris, and to a lesser extent Newsom, are considered to be “next in line.” That kind of thinking gave the Democrats Walter Mondale in 1984 and Clinton in 2016 and it gave the Republicans Bob Dole in 1996. Those elections did not go well for those who claimed a seniority right to the nomination.
Our best chances are Michigan Gov. Gretchen Whitmer, Pennsylvania Gov. Josh Shapiro and Kentucky Gov. Andy Beshear. Whitmer won reelection last year with 54% of the vote. Shapiro has a 64% approval rating. Beshear easily won reelection in a state that went overwhelmingly for Trump. That means all three have an excellent chance of winning Michigan, Pennsylvania and Wisconsin. Do that and Trump is defeated.
Right now this feels like a parlor game because the stubborn Biden is dug in and the party is senselessly rallying behind him. Yesterday he said his horrible performance was the result of two recent trips overseas. Well, foreign travel and a busy schedule are part of the job. Also, Biden can sleep on the plane. He’s not traveling coach. And a week at Camp David wasn’t enough to cure his jet lag?
Desperate excuses like that one and more reports of Biden’s decline could combine with bad polling numbers to get Democrats to muster the strength to replace him. If they do there’s no point in swapping him out with someone who is politically correct but whose chances to win are no better.
And on a related note… In recent weeks I’ve put Biden’s chances of winning at about 40% (I reduced that to 20% after his debate performance.) I pulled that number out of a hat, more or less. It was just feel. Well, Nate Silver, who crunches numbers for a living, put Biden’s chances at 35% before the debate, pretty close to my 40%.
Yellow Stripes & Dead Armadillos 
Josh and Andy who? Gretchen maybe is a little more well known among people who pay close attention to politics. Noisome, maybe a bit more, but he likely knows it’s not his time, yet. The other three look like they’re queuing up. 4 months to go and they have to build up name recognition. That’s a tall order.
Harris is a boat anchor. ‘There will be an uproar’. Who’s going to be doing the yelling?
Killary is my bet. She’s already got a line of swag out:
LikeLiked by 1 person
The first order of business is applying continuous pressure on Biden to withdraw from the race. That is done by calling/writing Democratic House and Senate members every single day to grow a spine and to send a delegation to the White House no later than next week. It helps to appeal to their self-interest by pointing out the severe damage that Biden is already inflicting on Democrats in down-ballot races. Those who are running for reelection this November will be out of a job if they meekly stand by while Biden steers the ship at full speed into a sea filled with icebergs.
Given the realities of today’s broken Congress, no president can get anything done without his party gaining and keeping control of the Presidency, House, and Senate. With Biden’s bunker mentality, the November election will be a complete blowout, with Republicans in control of every lever of power, forever and ever. Every day that goes by with Biden senselessly digging in his heels makes that outcome more likely.
So let’s fill every channel of communication with the message that Biden must do what is right for his party and the nation and announce his decision to withdraw from consideration for his party’s nomination. Then we can turn our attention to what a compelling and electable ticket looks like.
LikeLike