How Much Will Roe Matter?

Before the Supreme Court overturned Roe v. Wade last week abortion did not even register as a significant issue among voters. That’s probably because it seemed like settled law; not something you really had to think about. In fact, the level of public support for Roe remaining the law of the land had been remarkably consistent over five decades, at around two out of three Americans.

That should add up to a boon for Democrats in the coming elections. But will it? It might not because the question is one of intensity. Most of us are pro-choice, but we support some restrictions. The Bill Clinton formulation that abortion should be, “safe, legal and rare” hits the sweet spot of public opinion pretty well. But the new mantra of abortion rights activists, which will likely be conflated with the Democrats whether they want it to be or not, is, “free abortion on demand without apologies.” That’s a level of intensity that will turn off most pro-choice voters who have some reservations about it.

The other issue of intensity revolves around just how important this is to voters compared to other issues. If inflation continues to rage it seems unlikely that abortion will overtake it as a top issue. Inflation impacts everyone while most of us won’t consider getting an abortion or knowingly know anyone who would, even if we want others to have that option. Abortion is a choice I want available to others, but not something that impacts my daily life.

I’m skeptical that the passion of protestors will be matched by voters.

In fact, I can name at least ten issues that are more important to me than abortion. First, there are five big picture international issues. Climate change is the most important issue to me because it effects everything. Next comes right-wing populism because that looks like a worldwide resurgence of fascism. Then there’s the challenge of China because that’s a nation that appears about to supplant the U.S. as the dominant world power, and they will not be spreading liberal democracy. The war in Ukraine takes the next spot because the naked aggression of Vladimir Putin must know some bounds. Then there’s migration — partially linked to climate change — because that’s the unsettling engine that drives fascism.

Then I’ve got five — what I hope are — temporary national issues. I would lead with the ongoing effort to undermine our elections, then inflation, then crime, especially gun violence, then the intolerance of the new left (wokism, if you will) and finally the need to build a stronger social safety net in things like health care, chid care, expansion of Medicare and the like.

Don’t get me wrong. I am pro-choice. I think the Court was wrong to overturn Roe. I hope that this will help Democrats. I think this is a very serious and important issue. But I’m also hard pressed to put abortion above any of those 10 issues in terms of importance to me, or for that matter, for the country or for the world as a whole. I understand why pro- and anti-abortion activists are passionate about their issue, but I just don’t happen to share their passion and I suspect that will be the case with most Americans, even pro-choice voters.

We’re getting strong statements from Democratic candidates and office holders and breathless reporting and commentary on this from my usual liberal news sources — the New York Times, NPR and PBS. To liberal elites the Roe decision is eclipsing everything else. But I don’t think that’s the way the bulk of American voters will look at it. If Democrats take their cue from their elites — both on the “no apologies” messaging and on the relative importance of this issue vis a vis others — they’ll likely take an even bigger pounding than had been expected before last week.

If I were a Democratic strategist I’d stick to “safe, legal and rare” and I’d emphasize the fight against inflation and crime with abortion an add-on issue.

And on another matter… at last weekend’s state Democratic convention Mandela Barnes and Sarah Godlewski were tied in a straw poll of delegates for their preference for a candidate to take on Sen. Ron Johnson. Each received about a third of the votes. Billionaire’s son Alex Lasry got only 15%.

Want to read more curiously conservative views from a liberal? Pick up a copy of Light Blue: How center-left moderates can build an enduring Democratic majority.


Published by dave cieslewicz

Madison/Upper Peninsula based writer. Mayor of Madison, WI from 2003 to 2011.

5 thoughts on “How Much Will Roe Matter?

  1. I think you miss the point that abortion is not the issue – it is women’s health. It is a safety net issue. State’s are imposing constraints on the health care women can receive. Emotional as well as medical health. It has become clear to me that it is a question of choice: women should be able to choose health care that is safe and rare.


  2. You’re right – there are a lot of critically important issues that we need to focus on. However, the decision by the court took away a woman’s right to make reproductive health care decision. Women should have the right to make their own health care decisions. That’s why this a very big deal. Women come to the decision to terminate a pregnancy for a whole host of reasons – being still a kid themselves and terrified, finding out the fetus you are carrying has a life limiting disease, and on and on.

    If you know 5 women – you likely know someone who has faced this decision. I’m well beyond the years when pregnancy is an issue so maybe this shouldn’t seem like such a big issue. I can understand though why it is to so many who are younger – I can understand why this should be an important issue for all of us. Try to imagine having a court take away your right to make your own healthcare decisions.

    P.s. keep on writing – from a faithful reader who usually agrees with you wholeheartedly.


  3. You ironically imply “Democrat elites” care most about roe v wade as if it is not consistently working class and poor people who will face the brunt of these decisions. The issue is abstract for YOU because YOU are the privileged elite and the fact you think it’s abstract shows just how out of touch you are with everyday people.


    1. It’s a question of how much it registers in polls and how much it motivates voters. I’m saying that it’s unlikely to move a enough voters to make as much of a difference as issues like inflation, crime and immigration. I actually hope I’m wrong about that.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: